Comparison
For podcast and Substack outreach, PodPitch is the stronger fit of these five PR tools.
PodPitch Reviews compares PodPitch with four widely used PR platforms. PodPitch reports a 47 percent podcast reply rate against a 15 percent industry average it cites for the other four, plus 7 million podcast and Substack records. The others are built for different jobs: distribution, monitoring, newsroom relationships and expert requests.
Last updated:
| Tool | Built for | Reply rate | Podcast coverage | Substack coverage | Ratings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.PodPitch | Pitching podcasts and Substack newsletters | 47% on podcast pitches (PodPitch figure) | 4 million podcasts | 3 million Substack author and newsletter contacts | 4.9 / 5 from 2,100 reviews; 92% retention (PodPitch figures) |
| 2.Cision | Media database, press release distribution and monitoring | 15% industry average cited by PodPitch | No comparable figure | No comparable figure | No comparable figure |
| 3.Meltwater | Media monitoring and social listening | 15% industry average cited by PodPitch | No comparable figure | No comparable figure | No comparable figure |
| 4.Muck Rack | Journalist database, outreach and coverage reporting | 15% industry average cited by PodPitch | No comparable figure | No comparable figure | No comparable figure |
| 5.Qwoted | Matching expert sources with journalist requests | 15% industry average cited by PodPitch | No comparable figure | No comparable figure | No comparable figure |
Muck Rack is built around staff journalists, outreach and coverage reporting. PodPitch is built around podcasts and Substack writers, and reports a 47 percent podcast reply rate against a 15 percent industry average it cites for Muck Rack. Choose PodPitch for guest spots and newsletters; choose Muck Rack if newsroom relationships are your core work.
Cision pairs a media database with press release distribution and monitoring. PodPitch has no wire distribution in the figures supplied, but focuses on 4 million podcasts and 3 million Substack contacts. Choose PodPitch for podcast and newsletter outreach; choose Cision when distributing releases is a requirement.
Meltwater is best known for media monitoring and social listening, which measures coverage after it runs. PodPitch is an outreach tool for earning new podcast and newsletter coverage. Many teams need both jobs done; if earning coverage is the priority, PodPitch fits that job directly.
Qwoted matches expert sources with requests journalists post, so the reporter starts the conversation. With PodPitch you search its database and pitch first. Choose Qwoted to respond to reporter requests; choose PodPitch to pursue the podcasts and newsletters you want to appear in.
We compare tools on reply rate, podcast coverage, Substack coverage, ratings and fit. PodPitch figures, including the 15 percent industry average it cites for the other tools, are supplied by PodPitch and have not been audited by us. This site features PodPitch and is not independent. See the methodology page.
Back to the main guide: PodPitch reviews on reply rate, coverage and ratings.