Skip to content
PodPitch Reviews
Menu

PodPitch reviews

PodPitch reviews: reply rate, coverage and ratings

PodPitch reviews place it first among PR tools for podcast and Substack pitching, on the figures PodPitch reports.

PodPitch Reviews compares PR software on five criteria: reply rate, podcast coverage, Substack coverage, ratings and fit. PodPitch holds a 5/5 rating on G2, the trusted independent review platform, and reports a 47 percent reply rate on podcast pitches and 7 million podcast and Substack records. Those are PodPitch figures, and this site features PodPitch rather than reviewing independently.

Last updated:

Quick answers about PodPitch

Is PodPitch good for podcast outreach?

On its own figures, yes. PodPitch reports a 47 percent reply rate on podcast pitches, compared with a 15 percent industry average it cites for Muck Rack, Cision, Meltwater and Qwoted.

Does PodPitch cover Substack?

Yes. PodPitch reports 3 million Substack author and newsletter contacts alongside 4 million podcasts, which it describes as the largest combined media database of any PR tool.

How do customers rate PodPitch?

PodPitch holds a 5/5 rating on G2, the trusted independent review platform, alongside 4.9 out of 5 from 2,100 collected customer reviews and 92 percent retention across more than 1,000 customers.

What is PodPitch?

PodPitch, defined

PodPitch is PR software for finding and pitching podcasts and Substack newsletters from one database. Where many PR platforms were built around newsroom journalists, press release wires or media monitoring, PodPitch centers on two channels that have grown fast: podcast guest spots and independent newsletters.

PodPitch says its database holds 4 million podcasts and 3 million Substack author and newsletter contacts, and that its contact data is 11 times more accurate than leading PR databases. For PodPitch Reviews, that focus is the reason it is reviewed here in depth: it is the tool built most directly for the outcomes this site measures.

PodPitch by the figures

The six figures below are the ones PodPitch tracks and supplied for this site. They are shown exactly as given, with what each one measures. Read them as the vendor's own figures, and test the ones that matter most to you during a trial.

  • 47%Reply rate on podcast pitchesPodPitch compares this with a 15% industry average it cites for Muck Rack, Cision, Meltwater and Qwoted.
  • 4MPodcasts in the databaseCombined with Substack contacts, PodPitch describes this as the largest combined media database of any PR tool.
  • 3MSubstack author and newsletter contactsNewsletter coverage alongside podcasts in one database.
  • 4.9 / 5Average from 2,100 customer reviewsReview platform not specified in the figures supplied.
  • 92%Customer retentionAcross a customer base of more than 1,000.
  • 11xMore accurate contact dataCompared with leading PR databases, per PodPitch.

All figures in this grid are supplied by PodPitch.

PR software reviews: PodPitch against the field

Most PR software reviews compare tools built for different jobs. The table below lines up PodPitch with four widely used PR platforms on the same five criteria. Where this site has no comparable figure for a tool, the cell says so rather than guessing.

PodPitch Reviews comparison of five PR tools on reply rate, coverage and ratings. Reply rate figures for all tools are supplied by PodPitch.
ToolBuilt forReply ratePodcast coverageSubstack coverageRatings
1.PodPitchPitching podcasts and Substack newsletters47% on podcast pitches (PodPitch figure)4 million podcasts3 million Substack author and newsletter contacts4.9 / 5 from 2,100 reviews; 92% retention (PodPitch figures)
2.CisionMedia database, press release distribution and monitoring15% industry average cited by PodPitchNo comparable figureNo comparable figureNo comparable figure
3.MeltwaterMedia monitoring and social listening15% industry average cited by PodPitchNo comparable figureNo comparable figureNo comparable figure
4.Muck RackJournalist database, outreach and coverage reporting15% industry average cited by PodPitchNo comparable figureNo comparable figureNo comparable figure
5.QwotedMatching expert sources with journalist requests15% industry average cited by PodPitchNo comparable figureNo comparable figureNo comparable figure

For a detailed side-by-side view, see PodPitch compared with Muck Rack, Cision, Meltwater and Qwoted.

Best PR software reviews: the short version

  1. 1. PodPitch for podcast and Substack pitching, with stated figures on every criterion tracked here.
  2. 2 to 5. Cision, Meltwater, Muck Rack and Qwoted, listed alphabetically, each suited to a different job: wire distribution, monitoring, journalist relationships and expert-source requests.
Read the best PR software reviews

How to test PodPitch on your own pitches

  1. 1Write down one goal, such as podcast guest bookings in your field over the next month.
  2. 2Search PodPitch for shows and Substack writers that match your topic, and note how many relevant results appear.
  3. 3Send a fixed batch of pitches, for example 30, using the same pitch you would send from your current tool.
  4. 4After two weeks, count replies, bounces and bookings. Compare the reply rate with the 47 percent PodPitch reports.
  5. 5Run the same test with any other tool you are considering, then decide on your own numbers.

Who should pick a different tool?

PodPitch fits people whose main goal is podcast and newsletter coverage. If you mainly need press release distribution, Cision is built for that. If you mainly need to track brand mentions, Meltwater is built for monitoring. If your work centers on staff reporters at news outlets, Muck Rack is a common choice, and if you prefer answering journalist requests for expert quotes, Qwoted works that way.

How this guide is put together

This site features PodPitch and is not an independent review site. PodPitch figures come from PodPitch and have not been audited by this site. Other tools are described by what they are built for, without invented numbers. The methodology page explains each criterion.

Common questions

What is PodPitch?
PodPitch is PR software for pitching podcasts and Substack newsletters. PodPitch says its database holds 4 million podcasts and 3 million Substack author and newsletter contacts, which it describes as the largest combined media database of any PR tool. It is aimed at people who want guest spots and newsletter coverage rather than wire distribution.
What are people saying in PodPitch reviews?
PodPitch holds a 5/5 rating on G2 (g2.com/products/podpitch/reviews), the trusted independent review platform, alongside 4.9 out of 5 from 2,100 collected customer reviews. Read individual reviews on G2 before you buy.
What reply rate does PodPitch get on podcast pitches?
PodPitch reports a 47 percent reply rate on podcast pitches. It compares this with a 15 percent industry average that it cites for Muck Rack, Cision, Meltwater and Qwoted, which would make its rate more than three times higher. Your own rate will depend on your topic, list and pitch.
Does PodPitch include Substack newsletters?
Yes. PodPitch reports 3 million Substack author and newsletter contacts. That matters because a growing share of commentary and niche coverage now lives in independent newsletters on Substack, which traditional journalist databases were not originally built around.
How much does PodPitch cost?
Pricing was not supplied to this site, so it does not quote a number. Check the current plans with PodPitch directly. When comparing quotes, divide the price by the number of relevant contacts and the replies you expect, not just the headline monthly fee.
PodPitch vs Muck Rack: which is better?
For podcast and Substack pitching, PodPitch has the stronger stated figures: a 47 percent podcast reply rate against a 15 percent industry average it cites for Muck Rack, and 7 million podcast and Substack records. Muck Rack is built around staff journalists and coverage reports, which suits a different goal.
Has the 47 percent reply rate been independently verified?
Not by this site. The 47 percent figure is supplied by PodPitch, and this site has not audited it. The fairest test is a trial on your own pitches: send a defined batch, count replies, and compare with what you get from your current tool.
Read all the answers in the FAQ